The Saints Suck. When Will it End?
Well...it was bound to happen. One of these days, the guys over at the Times-Pic would actually write an insightful article that was surprisingly thought provoking. Jeff Duncan nailed it with his latest article titled, "Missteps after 2006 season sent New Orleans Saints sliding backward."
In five words or less the article can be summed up like this: The Saints %*&$^ up. Duncan puts it more politely because, well, he has to...
The 2007 offseason set back the club's plans a full year and contributed to the 7-9/8-8 results the past two seasons.
No matter how you slice it, he speaks the truth. The 2007 off-season is proving to be a complete bust. Of the fourteen players acquired that year only six of them are still on the team. David Patten, Olindo Mare, David Jones, Kevin Kaesviharn, Brian Simmons, Andy Alleman, Antonio Pittman and Eric Johnson are now all gone due to various reasons. Troy Evans, Jermon Bushrod and Marvin Mitchell have still yet to truly make an impact, leaving Jason David, Usama Young and Robert Meachem as the only three players of significance on the roster from the 2007 class. Even that is debatable.
Duncan, however, thinks the class of 2008 shows promise.
The good news is the club got back on track last year. Vilma and Shockey joined free agents Randall Gay and Bobby McCray and rookies Porter, Hartley, Sedrick Ellis, Carl Nicks and Glenn Pakulak to give the Saints an impressive core of young starters.
That might very well be truel but, as Bill Parcells is famously noted for saying, a team is only as good as their record. With an 8-8 record, the Saints 2008 off-season hasn't proved anything yet. Better than 2007? That would seem to be the case. But is it safe to say the Saints are out of the woods and on the right track? Not so fast.
We've got no idea down what road the next season will travel. If it turns out to be yet another one of those mediocre outputs we're used to seeing than the 2007 off-season won't be viewed as a singular set back soley responsible for a franchise's downfall, rather just a continuation of a tradition of failure. Have the 2008 and 2009 off-seasons erased the misakes of previous years? Can the Saints finally break their culture of losing? It's certainly too early to tell.
44 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Come on!!!
Don’t be one of those fans that starts talking gloom and doom before the season even starts. I think that ending 8-8 after loosing Colston, Bush, McAllister, Shockey, McKenzie, and Moore for at least part of the seaason, shows just have deep we are. And we are even deep this year. We have fixing the kicking problem, fixing the short yardage problem with Heath Evans and Pierre Thomas, and the cover problem with Sharper, Prioleau, and Greer and we still have the draft. We are closer to being an elite team than we have ever been. I’m more excited about 2009 than I was about 2006. We have weapons in every position. So, let’s stop here with the loosing attitude. If the fans have a loosing attitude the team will also. Let’s get behind this team and get our heads up and enjoy having a great team in New Orleans. Who Dat!!!
love the fire...
how long have you been a fan?
Our fearless leader here is being cautious ( and stirring the pot im sure ).
Some of us have not fully mended all the parts our beloved Saints kicked us in last year yet. Give us that opening kickoff and even Saintsational will be all fired up for a run to the playoffs.
MT
Sorry Big
Saints secondary remains a question mark to me. And seeing all those over thirthy players signed on FA (Prioleau, Sharper, Coleman, Dinkins, Spice) still doesn’t put my mind to ease. Guess I’ll stick with Dave’s “Cautiously optimistic” mantra at least until training camp.
SB minus just a D above average.
I feel the same way
But some guys’ wounds heal a little slower. Much harder for them to forget that pain. Many of the weaker have become Patriots fans, or Steelers fans. But we didn’t need them anyway.
I bought something big at the hardware store yesterday, guy had to help me carry it out. He saw the fleur de lis on the car. “You a Saints fan? Me too!” Hmmm. I asked my wife if she EVER remembered ANY Saints fans in Wichita before 2006: No. Bandwagon effect. I predict more of this in 2009. It’s going to be a big year.
GW: "Sean, I can’t do anything with this guy."
I have to agree with the writer that the 2007 off-season sucked, but drafting Meachem was the worst move we made. I studied the players coming out that year and based on need there 5 players we should have targeted. Four of them were Corners, and they were all gone before we picked. The last player that filled a need and had a first round grade was available when we picked: Greg Olson. We needed a TE, Payton and Loomis had both said so in the weeks leading up to the draft. I can not fathom why they didn’t draft him. If we had picked him, we wouldn’t have traded for Shockey last year. We would have our 2nd and 5th round picks this year.
Does anyone else think Meachem is worth this?
Meachem+Shockey>Olson+2nd+5th
I thought this was a horrible move as soon as they announced the pick and it has only looked worse over time.
Teams can not miss on their first round picks and be successful. Look at the Lions if you need proof. Free agent signings can be hit or miss, you do lose cap space, but the opportunity cost of missing on a first round pick is huge.
by saintsdevotee on Apr 5, 2009 8:44 AM CDT reply actions 1 recs
Boom, rec'd it!
Jeff’s right too. The 2006-2007 offseason was a disaster.
Great point about Greg Olsen. I remember wondering why Payton chose Meachem over Olsen on that draft day. Meach can still prove to be a good pick. He has shown flashes of greatness before. I’m not sure why he hasn’t gotten more playing time other than the fact that he has a few really good WR’s ahead of him on the team. Maybe it’s due to poor blocking skills? Payton has never said. This is his make or break year.
Go Saints!!!! Deuce may be gone, but he will never be forgotten.
by David "Satch" Kelly on Apr 5, 2009 10:37 AM CDT up reply actions
Every NFL team stumbles
But the New Orlean Saints organization has made more strides toward imroving this franchise over the past few years than they may have ever done.
What other Saints coach has been able to build such a solid offense in such a short period of time?
Signing Gregg Williams only solidified our beliefs that this team wants to be great.
Yeah we can look back on 07 and see that players didn’t pan out, but there’s no denying that this team is closer to great than they’ve ever been before.
Just because the monkey's off your back doesn't mean the circus left town - G. Carlin
by ty'76 on Apr 5, 2009 8:49 AM CDT reply actions 1 recs
Boom, rec'd it also!
I totally agree. The coaching changes will make a huge difference.
Go Saints!!!! Deuce may be gone, but he will never be forgotten.
by David "Satch" Kelly on Apr 5, 2009 10:39 AM CDT up reply actions
I agree with saintsdevotee here...
I was screaming at the TV on draft day that year for the Saints to pick Greg Olson and then when they picked Robert Meachem I was screming even louder saying “WHY???” and “NOT ANOTHER UT RECEIVER!!!” I hated the pick then and I hate where it puts us now as a direct result of that one dreadful pick. Don’t get me wrong. I love Shockey and what he brings to the team in terms of passion and desire and potential which will hopefully come to the surface full force this season or else that whole trade will have been a disaster as well for having taken away too many of our draft picks this year…
I HAVE ALWAYS BELIEVED IN THIS TEAM AND ALWAYS WILL!!!
KEEP THE FAITH!!!
WHO-DAT BABY!?!?!?
This Season Will Determine
If Meachem is a bust. He has shown some great promise. His stats are certainly phenomenal- yds per catch, % of catches for touchdowns, etc. For a guy who hardly played, he has performed whenever he could. Why Peyton doesn’t like him is a mystery but he has the physical attributes to be awesome and last offseason he buddied up with Patten and was a study in dedication to training. So, who knows.
Olsen, on the other hand, has played well but let’s not overstate it. He has only started 11 games in 2 seasons, only averages 3 passes per game- his stats are more like Billy Miller’s so far. Possibly Olsen will become a real force, but right now Shockey gets more receptions and is a bigger impact player even when he is injured part of a season. I don’t see Olsen taking over Tony Gonzalez’ crown of the best TE in the last decade.
I have high hopes for Meachem- I hope Peyton gives him a chance. He has the size, speed and talent that only a handful of NFL receivers have- Peyton should be able to work with that if he is a good coach.
Plus, I don’t understand the point above that said 4 draft picks above ours were corners and they were all gone before we picked. I guess the writer is saying we should have made a deal and picked higher up, but that is assuming the other teams would have made a deal. I don’t know who those 4 corners were, but I have a hard time believing that all 4 are now solid starters on good teams and that we could have had them. It’s all a gamble. I think Meachem will prove his worth.
4 corners
Going into the draft I had made a list of who I thought were our best possible picks, and 4 of them were corners. I wasn’t suggesting we should have traded up, because I expected at least one of them to fall to us. My point was that a WR wasn’t even on my radar as an area we needed to upgrade.
And the four corners I wanted were: Darrelle Revis, Leon Hall, Aaron Ross, and Chris Houston. All four started every game last season. Each is a solid cornerback.
I think the Saints are trying to get better, and more or less getting there. 2007 just happens to be a less year. 2006 was a stellar offseason: Brees, Bush, Colston. You can’t do better than that. I’m hoping 2009 is a more year.
p.s. Billy Miller is awesome! I’d love to have 2 of him and play out out of a 2TE Singleback set all day. Billy Miller is solid. He runs the right route, and catches the ball when he should. Shockey hasn’t progressed that far yet. I know he doesn’t have the speed Shockey does, but Olson does. With Cutler in Chicago, I would expect Olson to emerge as a top TE this year.
by saintsdevotee on Apr 5, 2009 12:02 PM CDT up reply actions
can't let this go unchallenged
Ok on Revis and Hall.
But Ross… I don’t think being prone to injury and getting benched throughout the season makes a player very attractive.
The Falcons are looking to replace Houston already.
GW: "Sean, I can’t do anything with this guy."
I wouldn't be so sure
I expect Houston and Chevis Jackson to start this year. While Houston’s never been more than solid in his short career, I can’t see the team making corner a high-round priority.
Hey Stujo- good point
I think you make a good a good point about the bandwagon effect in areas of the country outside of La. But, to add to it, there is also this – I have noticed in my area (Southern NJ) thatnthere are more people now willing to ADMIT they are Saints fans than before. There were always a few closet Saints fans around here, but now they actually show up at bars for games where the ticket is showing a Saints game and wear Black and Gold. But, I kind of empathize with their timidity, even though I wear my stuff proudly, because a few years ago I went to an Saints-Eagles game and almost got in a fight in line for a beer minding my own business but responding to some jerk where all I said was that Deuce already had 120 yards and it was only the third qtr. Up here, it is actually dangerous in certain situations to be a non- Eagles or a non Giants fan.
I saw the commercial
Dolphins fan woo hoo’d a play, he was the only one in a Jets bar. Be careful out there, man.
GW: "Sean, I can’t do anything with this guy."
All valid points
This year for 2009 is something to be proud of.
First of all, Think of what this offense is going to be.
1. Widerecievers. Colston and Arrington are Idential they are god given twins on the field. And when Arrington steps up the the plate. Add Moore( Pray to god he resigns) will scare the living daylights out of DBs in their postion. LOTS OF MAN TO MANa
You have a 4 wide reciever set,
1. Colston
2. Arrington
3. Moore
4. Mecheam, Henderson,
5. Have Reggie in the backfiled or split wide, And or add Thomas
6. With any of our Tighends ( remember our TE postions are not that bad)
Brees with his arm and HOLY you have something scary.
The NFL has NOT seen Arrington yet, so if he breaks out( and I am convenced he is the next Coleston.
That set alone is Man to Man and no way in hell can a Defense cover everyone of this power.
I expect a Very High scoreing Saints offense this year
As for Defense only time will tell. but remember my Post, the offense is only going to get better, As long as these guys stay Healthy, Look out Going to be lots of endzone dances this year.
What I think this year is going to see out of Meachum is he is going to get playtime, ( I hope) who knows, we may even trade him on draft day to someone who needs a reciever? Giants? Bangels? Jets? But with this core of recievers he will have more chances. Teams have to cover someone and if they know Moore, Arrington, Henderson( our deep man) and Colston are on the field. then Meachem is going to get the ball.
All you guys know that everyone of these recievers are deadly, even Meachem has shown promise, He just has to work hard in Practice
by Ranger565 on Apr 5, 2009 10:37 AM CDT reply actions 1 recs
Yeah!!!
That’s what I’m talking about. Get behind this team and loose the hate. Don’t be one of those fans that “Jump on the Bandwagon” when we start winning. Get on now, and we won’t have to talk about “YOU” later. It’s bad when I’ve got to jack-up this group. Man. Give me a break. Are y’all REAL Saints fans or a bunch of imposters?!!
C’mon you maggots, he can’t hear you.
GW: "Sean, I can’t do anything with this guy."
by stujo4 on Apr 5, 2009 3:10 PM CDT up reply actions 1 recs
sir YES SIR!!!
The Detroit Lions are on the clock!
by Hans Petersen on Apr 5, 2009 4:09 PM CDT up reply actions
Yeah, the count'll be much higher on a Sunday during the season...
The Detroit Lions are on the clock!
by Hans Petersen on Apr 5, 2009 9:04 PM CDT up reply actions
Yeah
The count will be higher when we start winning. Fare weather fans? I don’t care how long you’ve been a fan, just be a fan no matter what!!
by Big and Easy on Apr 5, 2009 10:07 PM CDT up reply actions
CAUTIOUS OPTIMISM from the DEUCE MCALLISTER of BLOGS - that's the key
I felt pretty good about what we had done in FA prior to the draft of 2007 to address our needs. Especially the JD acquisition just before the draft itself. Only time (2 seasons so far) is able to tell us how it actually works out.
During that 2007 draft, I also saw all the top-tier DBs go off the board early in Rd. 1, and one DB that some experts had us taking (Chris Houston from Arkansas) was still available…but apparently our guys didn’t have him rated high enough to take at that spot. He went to Atlanta, and I have not heard anything about him good or bad in regard to his ability or performance. So who knows if that was the pick we should have made? I don’t even know what DLs or LBs were still available at that spot.
Anyway, I’ll be cheering and hollering and hoping for the best BLESS YOU BOYS from now until they put me 6 feet under or illegally scatter my ashes from the rafters of the ‘Dome. I’ll also continue analyzing and discussing and sharing notes on this here CSC forever.
Cautious optimism is the key. I mean, the 2006 Chargers were 14-2 heading into the playoffs as the BIG FAVORITE and they flamed out in the Divisional Round after a bye. You’re only as good as the last game you played. That’s what makes it such a roller coaster – anything is possible. In 2006, we stomped the Cowboys on Sunday Night Football to stand at 9-4, and I thought we’d for sure finish 12-4 and maybe even catch the Bears for home field, but we didn’t. We stunk up the joint against the Skins, smacked down the Gaints, and then rested most of our starters against the Panthers to finish 10-6. You can’t count on anything in this league, but you (or at least I) gotta have faith, hope, and a tall, cool, bottle of CAUTIOUS OPTIMISM next to your remote control and laptop while you watch the Saints on DirectTV sunday ticket. Oh yeah, i’ll also be wearing my CSC shirt!!
The Detroit Lions are on the clock!
by Hans Petersen on Apr 5, 2009 10:40 AM CDT reply actions 1 recs
Cautious optimism be damned
We’re New Orleans…we don’t need no stinking caution.
RE-SIGN LANCE MOORE!
forget the caution
i’m running with our team till the light turns red and the way i see it, that won’t be for awhile with the possibilities that we have. i still say we need to draft jenkins even if we do have greer and porter as starters. is our depth really that great at the cb spot? also, why did we resign henderson? as much as i loved watching him make the deep catches and throwing the deep td pass to him on madden 09 i have seen him drop way too many balls. that wasn’t the case with meachem. also, will arrington get some minutes this year after being injured last year. same with demario pressley. plus we got sharper and cmon, i know the guy isn’t what he used to be with the packers, but he can still play some pretty good ball. i’m putting the pedal to the floor untill the season is over. we have enough pieces to be in the mix of superbowl calliber teams and we haven’t even had the draft yet. remember 2006, how the colts D had played like absolute crap untill the playoffs started. then they dominated every game they played w/ their D. we might be the best D all year but we have the talent to beat out every team. plus our offense is potent yet again. no, i won’t be cautiously optimistic about this season!! i refuse and we should forget the caution. i was that way last year, we didn’t have a huge splash last year in the offseason and we went offense in the 1st round of the draft. This year we have helped to sure up a secondary that has been weak even in 2006. i don’t plan on missing the playoffs this year. i’m proud to be a saints fan in indiana even if i’m the only one. i wear my bush and colston jersey’s every chance i get the chance to and plan on getting a vilma, fujita, or porter jersey this year. Who Dat!! Go Saints!!
Superbowl bound!!!...I hope? Go Saints! :D
Draft
Forget the Beanie Wells hoo-ha (He’ll be gone by #10, anyway). The Saints’ll trade back and try to get a 2nd or 3rd rounder. Besides, the one position they’ll address in the draft is OLB. Wonder why they didn’t address this in free agency? They’ve addressed FS and CB, and they’ll go with either Brian Cushing or Larry English. If they get a 2nd/3rd rounder, they try to go after Rashad Jennings. Then in Round 4, there’s OLB Zach Follett, who can groom under Dan Morgan.
That’s the way I sees it
Good points
I agree with you about Jennings…in fact, I think their interest in him is a good indication that trading back and picking up a second rounder is their plan. I don’t think they’re willing to take him with the 14th pick…but you never can tell. At any rate, I’d rather have Jennings than Wells.
RE-SIGN LANCE MOORE!
I Guarantee...
They’ll be targeting Brian Cushing (if not, Larry English, I just don’t see them going after Clay Matthews) in Round 1, If they get a Round 2 pick, definitely Rashad Jennings (Payton/Loomis will pull some strings and give up a 2010 3rd Rounder to get a 2009 2nd Rounder, you heard it here first), Round 4 they’ll go after Zack Follett and Bama Center Antoine Caldwell.
I can’t believe this Follett guy’s projected in Round 4. Watch this video and tell me he’s not a beast.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsr4YIWgazc
Can you imagine an LB corp of Cushing, Vilma, and Morgan/Follett? Dome Patrol 2.0, baby.
by Jee on Apr 6, 2009 1:55 PM CDT up reply actions
Our third for someone else's second?
Whoever that team is, can we trade more with them?
When we got Arrington with a seventh, we had to give up a sixth to get the pick. I don’t think anyone is going to give us their second for our third.
RE-SIGN LANCE MOORE!
Only way to get a second
The only way we can get a second is to trade back in the first round, and I would strongly advocate this. We move back to the 23rd spot we could add a late second rounder. I posted in another thread that I think we can do just that by trading with the Patriots. They have a slew of picks and might want to jump up and grab a LB.
The only other way would be to give up next years first for a second this year, and I think that’s a terrible idea. A team should never give up thier first round pick like this. You see teams do it, but it is rarely ever worth it.
by saintsdevotee on Apr 7, 2009 11:32 AM CDT up reply actions
hahahahahahahahhahahahahaha
The Detroit Lions are on the clock!
by Hans Petersen on Apr 7, 2009 4:23 PM CDT up reply actions
or, to be more brief... L O L
The Detroit Lions are on the clock!
by Hans Petersen on Apr 7, 2009 4:24 PM CDT up reply actions
If I had the number I would
Why, you don’t think he’s lurking around, reading fan posts all day??
by saintsdevotee on Apr 9, 2009 3:25 PM CDT up reply actions

by 
























