Carolina Panthers 14 @ New Orleans Saints 16: Prediction Results and Voting
by Dave Cariello on Oct 5, 2010 12:00 PM CDT
Email
PrintEveryone's predictions from last week have finally been tallied, analyzed and formatted accordingly. They can be found in their entirety following the jump.
Once again we didn't have anyone get all three of their predictions correct but just as Meatloaf once sang, two outta three ain't bad. So today's ballot has seven nominee's, including stujo4 and pipr for the second time, who all came oh so close.
Look over the results then go ahead and cast your vote for the best predictor. The poll will be open for 48 hours, closing Thursday afternoon at 12pm.
| CSC Member | Predictions | Analysis |
| VAsaintsfan |
1. Saints have their best day (most yards) rushing the ball so far this year. 2. The Saints get at least 2 sacks on Carolina’s QB. 3. The Saints have at least a +2 turnover margin. |
YesYesNo Score Prediction: Saints 24-10 |
| 117decibels | 1. The Saints have at least 3 interceptions. 2. Lance Moore is held to under 50 yards receiving and returning. 3. Chase Daniel plays for at least one snap. |
No YesYesScore Prediction: Saints 24-9 |
| pipr | 1. The saints score at least 10 points in the first quarter 2. There will be NO special teams or defensive TDs by either team 3. The Panthers commit at least 3 turnovers |
No YesNo Score Prediction: Saints 34-20 |
| stujo4 | 1 Carney does not attempt a FG in excess of 35 yards. 2 Jonathan Stewart has less than 7 touches/carries in the game. 3 Panters are held to less than 120 yards rushing. |
YesNo YesScore Prediction: Saints 31-9 |
| dalleoman | 1. Each team attempts at least two fieldgoals 2. Ivory has at least 50 total yardsrunning and receiving. 3. Clausen is held under 200 yards passing. |
No YesYesScore Prediction: None |
| coldpizza | 1. Saints offense held under 30 points for the fourth week in a row. 2. Jimmy Clausen throws his first career TD pass. 3. Both DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart exceed their previous high marks for rushing yards in a game this season (64 and 43 yards respectively). |
YesYesNo Score Prediction: Saints 24-13 |
| NYSaint | 1 – saints rush for 120+ yards 2 – brees scores 3+ TDs 3 – saints get 3+ sacks |
YesNo YesScore Prediction: Saints 31-17 |
| Grumps | 1. Ladell Betts has most rushing yards by a Saint 2. Shockey has 50+ yards receiving and one TD 3. Defense returns to its thieving ways, taking the ball away at least twice. |
No No No |
| cajunsblues | Brees will throw for 400+yards Panthers will have 3 turnovers Panthers will have over 100 yards rushing as a team |
No No Yes |
| Generic Fan | 1. Sean will go for it on 4th and 1 in the second quarter 2. Jimmy Clausen will be sacked more than 2x 3. Anthony Hargrove will take a fumble recovery in for a TD |
No YesNo |
| xxMUCK_ITxx | Brees throws 0 INTS Chris Ivory has a TD’’ Saints have a def score |
YesNo No |
| Philinwood | 1) Defense achieves at least 3 sacks 2) Roby has at least 100 return yards 3) Colston has at least 7 receptions |
YesNo No |
| whodatone | 1. Drew brees passes for at least 350 yards. 2. Defense has at least two takeaways. 3. Roby scores a touchdown. |
No No No |
| nolanative | 1. Saints have at least 2 takeaways. 2. Four different Saints score. 3. Junior Galette finally gets in the game & has a quarterback sack, hurry or knockdown. |
No No No |
| MtnExile |
1. My first prediction is proven wrong. 2. That would make my prediction right, which causes an infinite loop in the space-time continuum, in turn causing unpredictable results such as Jimmy Clausen throwing for 98 touchdowns. 3. The Saints still win when John Kasay misses the last extra point. |
No No No |
| Jimbo3 | 1. Panthers have at least 3 turnovers 2. Panthers have more punts than first downs in the second half 3. Panthers score 17 with 3 FGs and one TD with a 2 point conversion. |
No No No |
| DrewBreesManCrush | 1. saints out rush panthers 2. saints get a st/def td 3. panthers swap qb’s at some point |
YesNo No |
| Grok Rocker |
1. Drew Brees passes for 250+ yards and 3+ touchdowns. 2. Heath Evans has at least one rushing or receiving touchdown. 3. Lance Moore returns a punt for a touchdown. |
No No No |
| Ponysaints | 1. Brees passes for at least 375 yards 2. Saints get at least 3 turnovers 3. Meachem and Greer score |
No No No |
| jon08ban | 1. Saints get early lead and Panthers try to come back in 2nd half 2. Carney misses a FG, gets the hatred of all that is black and gold 3. Panthers have final possession of game. |
No No No |
| SarahT |
Tracey Porter will score a TD off an interception. Saints will come back from being behind in the 2nd quarter. Chris Ivory will have his first TD in the regular season. |
No No No |
| clearlyvague | 1. Brees throws for 300+ and three tds 2. Clausen completes under 50% of attempts 3. Colston goes for 75+ receiving with a touchdown |
No No No |
| nanvinnie | 1. Saints Defense scores a TD 2. Malcom Jenkins nabs an INT 3. Meachem scores a TD |
No No No |
| jack_casse | 1. Saints run a fake field goal/punt 2. Panthers rush for over 150 yds.. 3. Colston catched TD pass. |
No No No |
| Andrew Juge | 1. Chris Ivory rushes for a touchdown 2. Devery Henderson goes for over 100 yards 3. John Carney misses a field goal |
No No No |
| daisy117 | 1. Panthers have the last points of the game. 2. Hartley starts and does not miss a FG or PA 3. Colston has at least one TD |
No No No |
| Monkey Poop Battle | 1.) The Panthers gain at least 130 yards rushing 2.) Brandon LaFell scores his first NFL regular season touchdown 3.) Both teams convert at least one 4th down conversion |
No No No |
| saintsbrasil |
1)Ivory scores his first nfl td 2)M.Colston has 80+ rec yds 3)A Defensive Back has a sack |
No No Yes |
| BigTMill | Panthers strike first Half time score 3 – 0 Panthers 2nd half it’s the Metchem and Moore show. |
No No No |
| Dan Kelly | 1. Drew throws for over 350 yards 2. Saints defense/special teams scores at least once 3. Roby gets at least one fumble recovery |
No No Yes |
| MiamiSaints | 1. Brees has touchdown pass of under 10 yards 2. Brees has touchdown pass of 50+ yards 3. Steve Smith sucker punches a teammate (Probably Clausen) |
YesNo No |
| Jaydawg | 1. Saints offense gets back on track 2. Panthers run game can’t be stopped 3. Brees will rock their world |
Not really. No No |
| Jabbadahut99 | 1. Chase Daniels gets some playing time and throws for his first TD pass 2. Tusk scores at least one TD 3. Jimmy Clausen throws for 2+ picks. |
No No No |
| cscmember | 1. Drew Brees will throw 2 TD’s in the 1st quarter 2. Carney will hit his 1 and only FG attempt from the right hash mark in the 2nd quarter 3. Clausen will be pulled in the 3rd quarter after his sixth sack of the day |
No No No |
| HansDat | 1) Drew Brees tosses a TD late for the winning margin. Right after that TD… 2) Defense forces a 3 and out on the Panters next drive, and then the… 3) Offense runs out the clock to end the game. |
No No Yes |
| ALAC | 1. DeAngleo Williams has his first 100 yard rushing game of the season. 2. Jonathan Stewart scores 2 rushing TD’s. 3. Jimmy Clausen does not throw an INT. |
No No Yes |
| saint boss hog | 1. jimmy graham will get atleast a 20 yard reception. 2.saints get atleast 2 takeaways 3.brees will throw for atleast 4 tds |
No No No |
| SAINTSfaninNC | 1. Roby gains over 100 return yards. 2. Shockey scores at least 1 TD. 3. Defense gets at least 2 interceptions. |
No No No |
| lovingmma25 | 1. Chase Daniels plays in the 4th quarter 2. Brees does the cabbage patch on his 3rd touchdown while Sean Payton does the Tootsie Roll on the sideline 3. Steve Smith breaks the same arm again on a touchdown attempt |
YesNo No |
| Tac Hammer | 1. Ivory gets more than 120 total yards with at least 1 td. 2. Drew’s QB game rating is at least 135. 3. Brees gets to sit out some of the 4th Q due to a high points lead. |
No No No |
| sXe hXc AMF | 1. Brees achieves a perfect passer rating of 158.3 2. Pierre plays and scores 2 TDs. 1 rushing 1 recieving. 3. The only Carolina TD is from Brandon Lafell |
No No No |
| Ball Hawk | 1. Saints will take 1 kick off to the house. 2. Steve Smith punches Jimmy Clausen in his squishy face. 3. Drew Brees tosses over 400yrds. |
No No No |
| vicvega26 |
1. Panthers open the scoring with a field goal and the Saints answer with a TD. 2. Vilma will have 8 or more tackles and either a fumble recovery or an interception. 3. Ellis gets 2 or more sacks. |
No No No |
| slumD | 1. Porter has a pick 6 2. Roby takes one back to the house 3. Heath Evans has a TD |
No No No |
| hakimdropstheball | 1. Panthers win TOP between 3 and 4 minutes. 2. Saints rush for UNDER 75 yards 3. Brees finishes with higher quarterback rating than Panthers QBs. (Beats them by more than 25 points) |
No No No |
| Dan Hu Dat | 1. Ladell Betts scores at least 1 TD. 2. Steve Smith scores at least 1 TD. 3. Saints defense scores at least one (includes one or moreTD and/or safety). |
No No No |
| Breesus Christ Superstar | Saints rush for less than 100 yards Panthers rush for less than 100 yards Saints have a defensive score |
No No No |
| SaintBevo |
No No No |
|
| SaintsFanMD | 1. Drew throws for 350+ yards and gets over a 110 QB Rating. 2. At least 4 different Saints score. 3. Saints at least +2 in TOs for the game. |
No No No |
| GRIZZ | 1. Saints get 2+ turnovers 2. Colston scores at least twice 3. Both Panthers backs run for at least 50 yards each |
No No No |
| jray2000 | 1. Saints will score at least two defensive TD’s 2. Brees 300+ yds passing 3. Saints RB’s combine for 150+ yds rushing |
No No No |
| mississippisaintsfan |
1 Panthers turn the ball over 2+ times 2 Saints runners have over 100 yards rushing 3 Drew Brees is replaced by Chae Daniels for atleast 1 play during the game |
No YesNo |
| PanheadCatahoula | 1) Saints make 3 field goals 2)Saints score on pick 6. 3) Shockey catches TD pass. |
YesNo No |
| OldFartFan |
1 Daniels scores a TD 2Shanley has Int 3 Pampers have 4 turnovers |
No No No |
| Jay Preece | Meachem scores his first TD of the season. Roby takes a kickoff return for 50+ yards. Greer creates a turnover via INT or FF. |
No No No |
| saint_chew | 1. One quarter will be scoreless. 2. Saints Defence recover a fumble for a TD. 3. Clausen is benched in the 3rd quarter. |
YesNo No |
| chicago cajun |
1. Brees throws at least one interception 2. Panthers turn over the ball at least 2 times 3. Saints block a field goal attempt by the Panters |
No No No |
| FrenchFreak | 1. Jenkins gets a pick. 2. Brees is held beneath 225 yds passing 3. Both Carolina’s RBs (Williams and Stewart) score a TD |
No No Yes |
| Dan39465 | 1. Greer gets a pick 6 2. Brees has a passer rating >110 3. Bust gets over 120 mutipurpose yards. |
No No Who? |
| jeremysherwin | Saints win T/O ratio by at least 2 Brees 275 yards with at least 3 TD Steve Smith (Panthers) does not score! |
No No Yes |
| skinnykinney | 1. Brees and the offense will have 0 turnovers and 2 or less sacks. 2. Brees has at least 1 pass completed for 40 or more yards. 3. Defense has at least 3 TOs. On one of the TOs they either score or get the ball inside of the Panthers 25 yard line giving the O a short field to work with. |
No No No |
| bondcrash |
1) Brees has a passer rating higher than 120 2) Ivory scores at least 1 TD 3) We held their running game below 4 yards per carry |
No No No |
| gavin31785 |
1. Drew Brees throws zero interceptions 2. Carolina turns the ball over 2+ times 3. Ladell Betts runs for over 50 yards and 1 TD |
YesNo No |
| HB-NOLA | 1. Drew Brees throws 320+ yards and 3 TDs; passer rating over 100. 2. Will Smith and Sedrick Ellis each get a sack (possibly sharing credit on one play). 3. Saints get 3+ takeways from Carolina (defense and/or special teams). |
No No No |
| were gonna need a bigger boat | 1. Brees throws atleast 300 yards and 3+ TD’s. 2. Clausen (or Moore, depending on who starts) throws atleast one pick. 3. No RB on either team rushes for more than 130 yards. |
No No Yes |
| saints fan in cowboyland! | Brees throws for over 350 yds meachem scores a td will smith causes a fumble |
No No No |
| iiAndyiiii | Saints FB or TE scores at least one TD Saints RBs combine for >100 yards rushing Saints are +2 or better on turnovers for the game |
No YesNo |
| metryman | 1.Brees 300+ / @least 2TDs 2.Colston scores 3.Saints D has a score. |
No No No |
27 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
This just in
My record on these predictions is utterly craptastic.
Football is easy if you're crazy as hell
I'm 1 for 12 for the season.
If it makes you feel better.
Week 5 matchup: Cardinals
Week 5 motto: I'm too young to have heart problems.
Um, Dave?
Let’s think this through. My first prediction was, “My first prediction is proven wrong.” You counted that as wrong. Therefore, my first prediction was correct. But that would make it incorrect, again validating it as a prediction. What’s more, my second prediction was that the resulting temporal flux would render results unpredictable. To demonstrate, I gave an example which did not occur, thus proving the unpredictable nature of the flux that I successfully predicted with my first prediction that was wrong. I don’t know how you can argue with a record like that.
It was worth the wait.
Very funny.
Wanna say something? Sign up! It's free!
by Dave Cariello on Oct 5, 2010 2:30 PM CDT up reply actions
Dave,
117decibels
1. The Saints have at least 3 interceptions. NO
2. Lance Moore is held to under 50 yards receiving and returning. YES
3. Chase Daniel plays for at least one snap. YES
There’s a great chance that I might have been caught up in that “temporal flux” thingy, but I don’t remember Chase taking a snap?
I think, therefore I am, I think.
He was the holder on Carney's kicks
That counts as a snap.
Wanna say something? Sign up! It's free!
by Dave Cariello on Oct 5, 2010 6:21 PM CDT up reply actions
Just a question...
How did my first prediction not come true?
" 1. Saints get early lead and Panthers try to come back in 2nd half"
This is just curiosity, trying to find out how you grade.
Week 5 matchup: Cardinals
Week 5 motto: I'm too young to have heart problems.
Way too vague...
1 – Define “early lead.” It’s too vague.
2 – I assumed “early” meant the first half, since the second part of the prediction references the second half. That being the case, the Panthers didn’t TRY to come back in the second half, they in fact DID come back and were winning 14-10 and 14-13.
I grade very specifically. That means terms like “early” should be replaced with numerical denominations, i.e. “first quarter” or “16 minutes.” That will help.
Wanna say something? Sign up! It's free!
by Dave Cariello on Oct 5, 2010 8:09 PM CDT up reply actions
Ok got it,
Thanks for the future reference.
Week 5 matchup: Cardinals
Week 5 motto: I'm too young to have heart problems.
MtnExile was ROBBED!!!
Start a write-in campaign MntExile!!!!!!
LOL
Oh Man, I want to be in that number; when the SAINTS go marching in. (To Indy) WHODAT
Oh WAIT!!!!!
That might change temporal flux!!!!!!!!!!!!
Oh Man, I want to be in that number; when the SAINTS go marching in. (To Indy) WHODAT
my predicitions
I got one YES! Personal best for the season.
"Emancipate yourself from mental slavery, none but ourselves can free our minds" -Bob Marley
by PanheadCatahoula on Oct 5, 2010 6:36 PM CDT reply actions
Its an honor to make it up to the big board
I made the pick about our running game before I knew PT was going to be inactive, but looking back it made me seem pretty ballsy didn’t it?
"I want to hand this trophy to the MVP of the Super Bowl -- and the MVP of the entire league.''
-- Saints coach Sean Payton, handing the Vince Lombardi Trophy to Drew Brees after Super Bowl 44.
pipr's first prediction is not correct
The Saints scored 0 points in the first quarter. They scored 10 in the 2nd.
Boom!
Good catch. No idea how that slipped past me. Shouldn’t even be on the ballot.
Wanna say something? Sign up! It's free!
by Dave Cariello on Oct 6, 2010 12:43 AM CDT up reply actions
How is NYSaint not winning?
He accurately predicted more sacks than VASaintsfan, and gave a specific minimum number of yards rushing. Those were definitely the most specific and “out on a limb” predictions.
no justice!
i’m glad someone noticed that….i think its cause dave buried my name at the bottom of the list. he left my name off the nominees last time i qualified!
i guess VASaintsfan’s predictions are more….accessible? i preffer my “more specific version”
Comments For This Post Are Closed
Secondary Sidebar
User Tools
Related FanPosts on Canal Street Chronicles
Related FanShots on Canal Street Chronicles
FanPosts
Community blog posts and discussion.
Recent FanPosts
