Saints @ Panthers: Prediction Results and Voting
by Dave Cariello on Nov 10, 2010 12:00 PM CST
Email
PrintEveryone's predictions from last week have finally been tallied, analyzed and formatted accordingly. They can be found in their entirety following the jump.
This week may have been our best round of predictions ever in the history of this contest with ten, count 'em ten, members going a perfect three-for-three. And a fair amount of them are legitimate predictions, too. The ballot is long and I think this one is gonna be a tough decision.
Look over the results then go ahead and cast your vote for the best predictor. The poll will be open for 48 hours, closing Friday afternoon at 12pm.
| CSC Member | Predictions | Analysis |
| cscmember | 1. Saints D will record atleast 3 sacks 2. Saints D will not give up a TD 3. Saints D will score |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 47-9 |
| stujo4 | 1 Moore will be replaced by Little Jimmy at some point in the game, for more than one snap 2 J Stewart will be held to under 60 yards rushing 3 Steve Smith will be held to under 90 receiving yards |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 29-3 |
| lovingmma25 | 1. Saints TOP will be over 30 minutes 2. Panthers will convert less than 5 third down conversions 3. Saints offense will have over 320 total yards |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 35-14 |
| mississippisaintsfan |
1 Saints defense gets 1+ interception 2 Saints defense gets 3+ sacks 3 Saints force 1+ fumble |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 28-10 |
| GSO Saints Fan | 1) Saints D scores at least one time. 2) Panters combined offense below 225 yards 3) Jimmy Graham gets a TD |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 38-13 |
| Philinwood | 1) Saints RBs combine for at least 150 yds rushing 2) Saints win turnover battle 3) Shockey scores at least 1 TD |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 35-17 |
| bondcrash |
1) Our D has its first pick-six of the season 2) Our D keeps their O at less than 250 total offense 3) Our TE’s receive for more than 75 yds |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 24-9 |
| were gonna need a bigger boat | 1. Saints have over 400 yards of total offense. 2. Brees throws 2+ touchdowns, 250+ pass yards, 1 or less picks. 3. Saints force atleast 2 defensive turnovers. |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 38-10 |
| Jesus1000 | Saints to win by at least 15 points Saints to make at least 3 TDs Saints to make perfect field goals |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: Saints 30-12 |
| dalleoman | 1. Carolina scores no more than 2 offensive TDs.(defensive and special teams tds do not count.) 2. Saints rush for 120 yards or more. 3. Carolina rushes for at least 100 yards. |
YesYesYesScore Prediction: None |
| Grumps | 1) Sharper has either a pick or recovers a fumble 2) Julius Jones leads all Saints RB’s 3) Will Smith and Alex Brown combine for at least two sacks. |
No YesNo |
| cajunsblues |
Saints have at least 35 minutes of Ball control Brees completes at least 27 passes Saints have one running TD that is for 30 plus yards |
No YesNo |
| CajunCavern | 1. Shockey scores. 2. Brees does not get sacked. 3. Defense forces 3 turnovers. |
YesNo No |
| jon08ban | 1. Saints either score a game winning drive or prevent one with under 3 minutes remaining. 2. Brees has 2 INT. 3. Saints D keeps the Panthers under 200 yards of Offense, while special teams give up more than 125 on returns (Punt, Free Kick, and Kickoff). |
No No Yes |
| David "Satch" Kelly | 1. Chris Ivory scores a TD 2. Sharper gets at least one INT 3. Brees throws no INTs |
No No No |
| theprogrammerman |
No No Yes |
|
| Whodat10 | Drew Brees throws for 320+ yds and 4 tds Chris Ivory rushes for 100+ yds Saints d gets 3 TOs including a Darren Sharper pick six |
No No No |
| Alex Saints | J Stewart Held under 75 yards rushing Brees rushes for TD Saints cause 2+ Turnovers |
YesNo Yes |
| clearlyvague | 1. Jabari grabs a pick in his triumphant return 2. Jimmy graham scores a td 3. JuJo scores on a screen of 20+ yds |
YesYesNo |
| coldpizza | 1. No rushing TDs for the Saints. 2. No successful 4th down conversions for either team. 3. Both Matt Moore and Jimmy Clausen take at least one offensive snap apiece for the Panthers. |
No No Yes |
| BLJew | 1. Saints D finds the end zone at least once 2. Payton looses a challenge 3. Saints score in every quarter |
YesNo Yes |
| Jeff.I.b | 1. Moore throws for over 250 yds no pics. 2. Brees throws at least 1 INT. 3. Saints Defense sacks more 2+ times. |
No YesNo |
| BigTMill | 1. Saints D gives up big run for 40+ yards 2. Heath Evens gets passing TD 3. Shockey gets into a fight |
No No No |
| Breesus Christ Superstar | 1. Saints D with at least 2 takeaways 2. Carolina has less than 100 yards combined rushing 3. Carolina runs a trick play |
YesNo Yes |
| sportsboy73090 | 1. drew brees throws 2+ td passes 2. sharper has a turnover of some form (pick,fumble recovery) 3. lance moore will score a td |
YesNo No |
| cajuncommando58 | Drew throw 4 TD’s Sharper gets pick-6 Ivory scores first TD |
No No No |
| Ponysaints | 1. Brees throws for at least 2 TDs with no ints 2. Saints win turnover battle 3. Defense and/or Special teams score at least 1 TD |
No YesYes |
| DrewBreesManCrush | 1) one turnover on downs for the panthers 2) brees rating is 110+ 3) excluding 1 long panthers run… saints hold panthers to under 50yds rushing. |
Yes No No |
| RogerMilla | Meachem td Brees more than 350 yds Saints Miss a Field Goal :-( |
No No No |
| iiAndyiiii | Saints have at least 120 yards rushing Brees QB rating at least 100 Saints at least +2 turnover ratio for the day |
YesNo No |
| Grok Rocker | 1. Drew Brees passes for 300+ yards and 4+ touchdowns. 2. Ivory rushes for 100+ yards and 1+ touchdowns. 3. Defense has 3+ takeaways including 1+ pick-six. |
No No No |
| MtnExile | 1. Drew Brees throws some passes. 2. At least one guy scores. 3. Charlotte remains an armpit. |
YesYesUnconfirmed |
| jful | 1. Saints score on their first possession. 2. Panthers’ QBs throw at least 2 INTs. 3. No Carolina RB tops 65 yards. |
No No Yes |
| MiamiSaints | 1. Panthers never lead 2. No challenges are won 3. Steve Smith sucker punches a teammate |
No No No |
| TAYDIGGA | 1.Drew Brees has his best game of season 317 yards No picks 2.One of our runningbacks has total of 170 yards 3.Sharper gets at least 1 pick |
No No No |
| BRSaintsFan | 1. A Carolina RB will have a run of 25+ yards. 2. Devery Henderson will receive a pass of 24+ yards. 3. Lance Moore will atone for his fumble at the goal line in the previous Carolina game by scoring in this one. |
YesNo No |
| hakimdropstheball |
1. "Orange Jullus" scores a touchdown. 2. Drew Brees completion rate is over 67%. 3. Saints finish at +2 in turnover ratio. |
No No No |
| whodatone | 1. Brees passes for at least 250 yards. 2. Shockey gets at least 2 touchdowns…running or passing. 3. Saints lead the entire game and are never behind. |
YesNo No |
| vicvega26 |
1. Brees has over 300 yards passing with at least 2 TD’s and at least 70 for completion percentage. 2. Neither team rushes for more than 50 yards. 3. The Saints defense has the same amount of sacks as they do turnovers. |
No No No |
| SaintBevo |
No No Yes |
|
| TComm | 1) Brees passes for 3 TDs 2) Defense gets 2 turnovers 3) Hartley is 2 for 2 on field goals |
No YesYes |
| AJG | 1. Panthers under 100 yds rushing 2. Saints get a pick-6 3. Chris Ivory 80+ yards rushing |
No YesNo |
| JayPreece | Will Smith records multiple sacks. James Anderson has at least 10 tackles (combined). Panthers have less than 300 yards rushing + receiving. |
No No Yes |
| therunningsaintfan | 1. Brees under 250 yards passing 2. Panthers Total offense under 300 yards 3. Defense gets 3 turnovers |
No YesNo |
| Cajun in CA | 1. Two different Saints’ tight ends score. 2. Neither team runs a trick play 3. JuJo leads all Saints RB’s in total yards from scrimmage. |
YesNo Yes |
| saintsfan77 | Brees throws 3 td’s shockey catches 1 td, saints D holds stewart under 100 yards rushing |
No YesYes |
| jray2000 | Ivory: Explosive play (20+ yds) for a TD Saints DEF: 2+ sacks Brees will complete passes to at least 7 different players |
No YesYes |
| SaintsFanMD | 1. Saints over 375 yds total offense, Panthers under 275 yds total offense. 2. Panthers held under 75 yds rushing, Saints finish with over 100 rushing yds. 3. Saints at least plus 2 in T/O ratio. |
YesNo No |
| HansDat | 1) Late 4th Q FG by Hartley puts game out of reach. 2) Red zone inefficiency continues to stymie NO (less than 30% TDs on trips in red zone) 3) Saints have more takeaways than giveaways. |
No No Yes |
| JAM13 | 1. Saints try at least one trick play in the game 2. J. Jones gets a rushing TD 3. Panthers Steve Smith gets at least 5o yards receiving. |
No No No |
| saints fan in cowboyland! | 1. Shockey scores 2. We score on a pick 6 3. Hartley has a perfect day with a 45+ yd kick. |
YesYesNo |
| Saintsfan75 | 1. D# tips a ball and Jenkins gets his first int of his career. 2. J. Graham FINALLY gets a TD 3. TFPK goes 100% for FG’s and PATs |
No YesYes |
| jeremysherwin | Saints Defense holds panthers to 1 TD or less. (does not include fumble/int’s returned for TD) Saints Defense holds panthers to under 100 yards rushing. Panthers have at least 2 turnovers. |
YesNo Yes |
| JREM |
1) Brees throws for 2 TDs, no INT (please????) 2) Sharper comes up with at least 1 turnover (fumble rec or int) 3) Lance Moore has more than 5 receptions and 1 TD catch! |
No No No |
| Dang Hu Dat | 1. Brees has at least 3 TD passes. 2. Saints defense gets at least 2 interceptions. 3. Saints defense gets at least 3 sacks |
No No Yes |
| Rocks | 1. Brees zero sacks 2. Panthers fewer than 175 passing yards 3. Saints exactly 1 rushing TD |
No YesYes |
| PanheadCatahoula |
1)Roby runback over 60 yards 2)Colsten, Meacham, Moore TD receptions 3) Bush gets in the game. |
No No No |
| saintsbrasil |
1.Saints D holds panthers Offense for 1 td or less 2.Brees throws 2+td´s and 1+int 3.Saints scores on a screen pass |
YesYesNo |
| Jabbadahut99 | 1. Hartley is perfect for the day in all categories. 2. Ivory scores at least once. 3. Jonothan Stewart is held under 100 yards rushing. |
YesNo Yes |
| Tac Hammer | 1. The Saints hold the Pant’s to a field goal only game. 2. Chase Daniels is involved in a trick play. 3. Tusk scores a TD. |
YesNo No |
| realheavyd | 1. The Saints defense finally get that elusive shutout they missed versus the Bucs. 2. Solid run/screen pass game from Ivory/Jones/Betts opens up deep ball threat BIG TIME! 3. Secondary, with Sharper, Porter and Greer all back in action, outdoes itself with turnovers. |
No Prediction unquantifiable Prediction unquantifiable |
| Dan39465 | 1. Brees QB rating >110 w/ no INTs 2. 3 different players catch TD passes from Brees 3. Defense gets 2+ sacks and 2+ takeaways. |
No No Yes |
| saint boss hog | 1.saints d will get atleast 1 pick 2.graham has a td or reception over 20 yards 3.colston will get atleast 1 td |
YesNo No |
| Monkey Poop Battle | 1.) No Saints receiver or running back has over 100 combined rushing and receiving yards. 2.) Saints force 3+ Panthers turnovers. 3.) Hartley kicks at least 2 successful field goals. |
YesNo Yes |
63 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I voted for Stujo
I think predictions that name players as opposed to a unit (like Saints D) should get greater consideration. Stu did that with all three of his.
My predictions this year always seem to be wrong. Think I’ll start taking the George Castanza approach and go with the opposite of what I think.
"As soon as Tony (Dungy) said we had no chance, I knew we had 'em right where we wanted 'em"--Coach Sean Payton right after Super Bowl XLIV with the Lombardi Trophy firmly in hand. WHO DAT!!
by David "Satch" Kelly on Nov 10, 2010 12:11 PM CST reply actions
Yeah vote for me! Check out that score: 3 for the Panters who are again in steep decline
George : My name is George. I’m unemployed and I live with my parents.
Victoria : I’m Victoria. Hi.
Thanks Satch!
I really wouldn't mind, but you know I've got my pride to think of, uh huh
...another reason not to vote for stujo:
He’s endorsed by CP!!!
:-P
;-)
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:42 PM CST up reply actions 1 recs
Is the score a determining factor, like the 4th prediction, or something to use as a tiebreaker to aid us when making a choice?
"In fact with that article from today that had him real lean and everything, I think I’m going to play him at corner this week in place of Tracy Porter."-Greg Williams in refefernce to Sedrick Ellis
Pay no attention to the score behind the curtain...
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:45 PM CST up reply actions
Then again,
I never made the accountability index…I feel like the red-headed stepchild…revenge…hehe…
"In fact with that article from today that had him real lean and everything, I think I’m going to play him at corner this week in place of Tracy Porter."-Greg Williams in refefernce to Sedrick Ellis
You’re on there as of Nov 8, for being a JuJo fan.
I really wouldn't mind, but you know I've got my pride to think of, uh huh
O joy O joy!
I’d like to thank the Academy Of Stu’s for this great honor. I’d like to thank my dad for teaching me how to be a smarta**, yada yada……
"In fact with that article from today that had him real lean and everything, I think I’m going to play him at corner this week in place of Tracy Porter."-Greg Williams in refefernce to Sedrick Ellis
I’m using scores as the determining factor in a tie. The logic being that if there’s no weight being given prediction boldness throughout, why use it amongst the perceived leaders in number of correctly predicted occurrences? For example, there could be multiple people with three ho hum correct predictions, yet one with two EXTREMELY bold picks correct, even to the point of prophecying specific details as to how two plays unfolded, players involved, etc. As is, the latter wouldn’t make the ballot.
"I was not on the boat in question" -Darren Sharper
Voted for GSO
I liked the specific call for Graham with the TD as well as the call of our D getting a score.
The Graham call was bold, true.
The voting is a tough choice. Stu got the score pretty close though.
"Relax, have a homebrew!"
Agreed, voted for GSO because of the D score and picking Graham’s first TD of his career.
"Aristotle was not Belgian. The central message of Buddhism is not 'every man for himself.' And the London Underground is not a political movement. Those are all mistakes, Otto. I looked 'em up."
Are you SURE those are the reasons?
Hope and change! Yes we can!
I really wouldn't mind, but you know I've got my pride to think of, uh huh
My opponent is not qualified to be a dog catcher!!!
Vote GSO for REAL change!!!
(…here’s a quarter…and a penny…OH LOOK, a Susan B. Anthony dollar!!! )
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:33 PM CST up reply actions
I’m blacker than Barack Obama!
I really wouldn't mind, but you know I've got my pride to think of, uh huh
Well...
…I’m 1/4 Seminole Indian, there for more of a TRUE AMERICAN!!!
:-P
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:38 PM CST up reply actions
yes i'm sure those are the reasons.
Despite what you think, i don’t really have a problem with you personally. I liked your predictions. But i felt guessing the Saints First defensive TD of the year combined with a rookie’s First ever TD…was just slightly more bolder.
"Aristotle was not Belgian. The central message of Buddhism is not 'every man for himself.' And the London Underground is not a political movement. Those are all mistakes, Otto. I looked 'em up."
Hey now, I’m not here to sway anyone’s votes. Stu’s predictions were good…let the candidates sway you with their money and food.
"Aristotle was not Belgian. The central message of Buddhism is not 'every man for himself.' And the London Underground is not a political movement. Those are all mistakes, Otto. I looked 'em up."
And since I'm the only candidate offering BOTH...
;-)
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 3:00 PM CST up reply actions
Lol.
No your arguments made sense to me, I actually agreed with all of what you wrote. Plus I can’t actually receive their money so their bribes are meaningless.
Week 10 matchup: Bye
Week 10 motto: Bye? Where are you going?
Hey, waitaminit!
I’m not running for the governership of California!
:-P
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 3:16 PM CST up reply actions
I have no money or food
But I do sale A/C equipment on the westbank if anyone is interested.
"I understand this is a violent game. It's the only place you can hit somebody and not go to jail. So you understand that it's a privilege to play this game." Danny Clark
PS - Off Topic
If anyone has been holding off getting Madden 11, the EA store has it on sale for 29.95. Use the code – EAPARTNERS2010 – for another 30% off taking it down to 20.96 with free shipping. I’m at an APO and had to pay 6.99 for shipping, but the total was still only 27.96. Now back to your normally scheduled Saints blog.
Great avatar^
"I understand this is a violent game. It's the only place you can hit somebody and not go to jail. So you understand that it's a privilege to play this game." Danny Clark
Voted Stu, close with the final score
You think you know, and you don't know, and you never, ever will.-Jim Mora Sr.
I'm gonna work this room like a Chicago politician
Vote for me! “A chicken in every pot!”
I really wouldn't mind, but you know I've got my pride to think of, uh huh
...pfft...
…I’m gonna work the room like a LOUISIANA politician:
“…a vote for me is $100 in your pocket!!!”
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:34 PM CST up reply actions
Chicken in every pot?
What is this? The Vikings blog?
Vote for me! A hamburger on every plate!
I like Hamburgers!
No!!
…remember that $100 will put a chicken in your pot AND a hamburger on your plate, with plenty left over for beer!!!
:-D
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:35 PM CST up reply actions
But..
….they’re REALLY GOOD photocopies, I have a $10K color lazer printer…
;-)
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:38 PM CST up reply actions
MMMMMMMMM, Burgers!
Letting all the candidates know that I do accept bribes. It will not in any way affect my vote, but I will accept your bribe.
"In fact with that article from today that had him real lean and everything, I think I’m going to play him at corner this week in place of Tracy Porter."-Greg Williams in refefernce to Sedrick Ellis
You really ARE from Baton Rouge!
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:41 PM CST up reply actions
Louisiana politics at its finest! :)
Louisiana politics: a spectator sport! More cash changing hands than all other pro sports combined!
"In fact with that article from today that had him real lean and everything, I think I’m going to play him at corner this week in place of Tracy Porter."-Greg Williams in refefernce to Sedrick Ellis
I used to hang out in the capital building when I lieved there...
…there were always a few stray 20’s floating around…
;-)
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:51 PM CST up reply actions
Panthers under 225 yds is a pretty bold prediction-GSO
Score in the ballpark too…
"In fact with that article from today that had him real lean and everything, I think I’m going to play him at corner this week in place of Tracy Porter."-Greg Williams in refefernce to Sedrick Ellis
Gahh I don't know who to vote for.
I vote for indecisiveness.
Week 10 matchup: Bye
Week 10 motto: Bye? Where are you going?
That guy ALWAYS wins when I'm voting for something...
…no he doesn’t……yes he does……no he doesn’t…yes he…
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 2:49 PM CST up reply actions
Too many fine predictions, Dave!
Can we call an audible since we have a bye week and nothing to do except root against the Dirty Birds, and have a runoff with the top two or 3 vote getters?
"In fact with that article from today that had him real lean and everything, I think I’m going to play him at corner this week in place of Tracy Porter."-Greg Williams in refefernce to Sedrick Ellis
I voted for Stu
but I’m going to vote again for cscmember and GSO. There were some really awesome predictions this week.
I just missed out, I nailed my first prediction though. (2 different tight ends will score for the Saints.) I should have been more specific with my 2nd prediction, I meant no trick plays like a fake field goal, punt, or surprise on-side kick. Kinda glad I missed out though, too many contenders this week.
Dorothy-"But how can you talk if you haven't got a brain?" Scarecrow- "I don't know, but some people without brains do an awful lot of talking." -Wizard of Oz
LOL
1. Drew Brees throws some passes.
2. At least one guy scores.
3. Charlotte remains an armpit.
Yes
Yes
Unconfirmed
Week 10 matchup: Bye
Week 10 motto: Bye? Where are you going?
Having spent time in cHarlotte...
…there is NOTHING unconfirmed about its armpittedness…
:-P
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 3:01 PM CST up reply actions
hey!
i had 3 right too!
Saints 34, Panthers 13
1. Saints hold Panthers to under 250 yds of offense.
2. 2+ turnovers for Saints D
3. Saints are 50%+ on 3rd down conversions (did you know we are 1st in that category in the NFL?…and 2nd in 4th down percent)
OK....
…1…2….3……4….7….6…5….8…..
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 3:21 PM CST up reply actions
Huh
I find your third down conversion percentage fact funny….since Mike Sando called out how poor we’ve been in 2 of our last three games on third down. If you’re curious our last 3 games…have been 33% 44% and 50%. Total the last 3 games we’ve been 42.2%….which would place us 8th in league. Way to not check your stats Mike Sando…..nice.
"Aristotle was not Belgian. The central message of Buddhism is not 'every man for himself.' And the London Underground is not a political movement. Those are all mistakes, Otto. I looked 'em up."
Does anyone realise that the poll is not in alphabetical order. There is a reason my predictions are first on the list.
"I understand this is a violent game. It's the only place you can hit somebody and not go to jail. So you understand that it's a privilege to play this game." Danny Clark
Yeah...
…you posted first in the thread, so it’s in order of which of the correct pick posts is first.
:-P
…were you implying yours is closer to accurate? Nice try!
;-)
Who Dat? TWO DAT! Do dat AGAIN!!!
by GSO Saints Fan on Nov 10, 2010 5:09 PM CST up reply actions
Another Write-In for MtnExile
His weren’t the the most detailed predictions, but they were the funniest, IMHO.
by Philistine on Nov 10, 2010 4:14 PM CST reply actions 1 recs
Mais! Next time I'm going to hold my vote until all the "campaigning" is done!
"Relax, have a homebrew!"
Stug got my vote...
although I was tempted by the write-in for ME. I even added a bonus to his predictions that was 100% spot on!
I think, therefore I am, I think.
Comments For This Post Are Closed
Secondary Sidebar
User Tools
FanPosts
Community blog posts and discussion.
Recent FanPosts
