Top 15 Starting RB rankings for next season
So, I'm going to try and do these rankings once a week for most positions during this offseason. To try and help with the no football situation. So for this week, I present to you my RB rankings. Unlike the QB rankings which had variables such as leadership, these rankings are purely from a statistical viewpoint and is just my humble opinion on this matter. I did not use any receiving stats which alters the rankings a bit and this is purely from a rushing point of view, which changes up the rankings for the RBs that can catch.
1. Chris Johnson: Safe pick to start us out. Broke the 2000 yard milestone last year, and historically the back who breaks it has an off year the next year, however I think he will still have a good year. 1600+ yards sound about right with approx. 14 TDs and 3 or 4 fumbles.2. Maurice Jones Drew: Staying on the safe route we shall cruise at 55 mph (approx 88 kph for our non-American friends). MJD is proving to be an elite RB as he will look good with/without the Jaguars Offensive line, which is great because they won't help him look good. Expect him to have a great year with 1500+ yards and approx 15 TDs and probably 2 or 3 fumbles.
3. Ray Rice: And off we go from the safe path and onto the "WTF is he thinking" road at approx 85 mph. Baltimore's O-line will improve this year and as most of us know, RBs and QBs look better with great O-lines than with crappy ones. Because of this I think he will leap frog AP to take the 3rd spot with 1500+ yards and 10-13 TDs and 4 fumbles.
4. Adrian Peterson: "Adrian, come sit down in my office. Now you are one of the best RBs playing the game right now, you can get yards in a game, you can break tackles, fake out the defenders, make a hole when there wasn't one before, and do a great job overall. Well almost. You see, last season you fumbled the ball 9 times and lost it 6 times when you include the postseason. And then of course there was that fumble in the NFCCG that was credited to Favre but you could have taken the blame as well. If you can just hold onto the ball you are easily top 2 talent yearly, instead I have to rank you 4th. I see you going for over 100 yards next year with 16 TDs, but I also see 8 fumbles with 6 lost. You learn to hold onto that ball, next year I can see you as #1. Can you do that for me Adrian? Good, oh by the way, I will forgive all fumbles during week 1. Your still trying to get used to working again. So get them all out while you still can, thanks AP for the time."
5. Micheal Turner: Micheal spent some time out last year with an injury and had a bad year when you compare it to the 2008 season. Micheal can be a great back and has the advantage of playing in a division that has a poor rushing defense which can help him build some numbers in the Falcons 6 division games. However I think this will be his last great year and will start to hit his decline after this year as he begins to start feeling some effects of age. That won't stop him this year from a 1400 yard season with 12 TDs and possibly 5 fumbles with 2 lost. He better be careful though or he could suffer from "Petersonitis".
6. Rashard Mendenhall: So the Steelers are without their starting QB for 4-6 games, and will have to use their backup. That's bad news for the team, good news for Mendenhall. With Ben out for a few games, the Steelers will probably want to run the ball more often to try and not have to put the game in the hands of the temporary starter unless forced to. Because of this, I see Mendenhall's numbers going up to about 1300 yards with low double digit TDs, with a fumble or two.
7. Steven Jackson: Jackson has now had 5 consecutive seasons with over 1000 yards rushing, which proves hes a great back to have and being 26 years old means he has 2 or 3 great seasons left before that decline starts to kick in. However a problem with Jackson is he is behind...the Rams line. The only worse thing imaginable in football is to be Al Davis' assistant, could you imagine? The fact that he rushed for 1416 yards last season proves he can bring it no matter who is blocking for him. I see a 1200-1400 yard season for him with 10 TDs, thanks to the fact the Rams now have a QB who the defense will now have to worry about they may stop worrying about the run 100% of the time and may focus on the run only 99% of the time this season.
8. Frank Gore: Gore is usually up higher on lists like this, but his injury problems are a concern, he hasn't has a full season since 2006 and in that year almost rushed 1700 yards. If he can stay off IR then he will have a great season and will be in the top 3 but I don't see him lasting all 16 games and this will drag him down in the stats again. I can see a 1300 yard season with 13 TDs and a few fumbles, but I might be stretching that a bit too far, unless he stays the whole season.
9. Shonn Greene: 540 yards rushing, with 2 TDs, not great numbers for a back but manageable. However, that was when he was the backup behind Thomas Jones who got over 1400 yards and 14 TDs. Behind the Jet's line, which is built for the run, he should see a great sophomore season. I see Greene breaking 1200 yards and may get over 1300, and having 12 TDs and 3 fumbles.
10.DeAngelo Williams: Williams should have a great year so long as he stays away from the injury bug. Playing all 16 games in 2008 he rushed for over 1500 yards and 18 TDs. The next season, when the Panthers went through a regression, he still rushed for over 1100 yards and got 7 TDs. As Moore starts to settle in to being the Panther's full time starter, the Panthers will probably try to go to the run in the early season so that should help pad Williams stats a bit more. He will probably get 1200-1300 yards and may get close to 10 TDs and 2 fumbles.
11. Cedric Benson: Benson had his breakout year last season, which is great because he's starting to run out of seasons. Benson will have a similar season next year as he did this past season. He should rush for 1200 yards and get about 8 TDs, with 2 fumbles.
12. Ryan Grant: Just like with Rodgers, Grant had almost no O-line help and still put up 1200+ yards and 11 TDs. With the O-line improvement, the conservative estimate is to have him have another 1200 yard season and 10+ TDs but if the Packers go the run instead of the pass this year, then prepare for some higher numbers. However, since the Packers have Rodgers they will most likely continue the same offensive plan they had last year, since it did great for them, until Rodgers lost the ball in the playoffs.
13. Jamaal Charles: Charles had a great sophomore season, rushing for 1100 yards and got 7 TDs although did suffer from a severe case of "Petersonitis" last season. However, his third season should improve as he starts to settle into the NFL. I can see a 1200 yard season with 9 TDs, although if he doesn't improve his carrying a bit, he could become the upper middle classes' Adrian Peterson.
14. Pierre Thomas: Thomas has yet to have a thousand yard season although the fact that in the 41 games he has played he has only started 12 of them could mean that if he were the starting RB for a full season (as will most likely be the case barring injury this next season) he can get 1000+ yards rushing with 8 rushing TDs easy with a fumble or 2. His 5.4 yards a carry does show promise if he were used as one of two backs instead of 3 as was the case last season.
15. Knowshon Moreno: I am assuming he becomes the starter of the Broncos here, and if so their running game will be a bright spot for them on offense when their passing game will likely decrease. In his rookie year he almost rushed for 1000 yards while only starting for 9 of the 16 games, while also getting 7 TD's. He was almost at 13 or 14, but then I took a look at fumbles. Congratulations we have a severe case of "Petersonitis". As a matter of fact, for every 62 touches Moreno got, he fumbled and lost the ball, compared to a 52 to 1 for Peterson, however didn't put up the numbers Peterson got. This looks worse when compared to Thomas with 147 touches and Johnson with 119 touches and Charles, who fumbled every 63.3 touches last season. He should be happy that he is in the severe stage, best to get it treated before it enters the acute stage.
Honorary Mentions:
Ronnie Brown,Joseph Addai, Jahvid Best,Ryan Matthews,Matt Forte, C.J. Spiller, Marion Barber:
Most of these are rookies, for the reason that we have no idea how they will act in the NFL. Some could be great, some busts. Because of this I will just give them honorable mention so i can gloat that I'm right either way. As well Brown can be great if he can stay off the IR and could have a great season, and I think Addai has one season left that he can get a good 900 yards. Forte might have a good season if the passing game improves. Barber could get 1000 yards next season, however, that's not a certainty, and he might start declining soon.
Well there you have it, 15 RBs that I think will be on the watch list and in the order I think too. Even if you disagree with everything I wrote, at the very least I hope I took some of this boring offseason off your mind and gave you a taste of football. Next week I will rank starting WR which will include WR1 and WR2.
This FanPost was written by a reader and member of Canal Street Chronicles. It does not necessarily reflect the views of CSC and its staff or editors.
69 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I seriously doubt Marion Barber gets 1000 yards this year. Both Jones’s and Choice’s workloads have been steadily increasing and they drafted a WR with their first pick. I would go so far as to say Pierre Thomas has a better shot at cracking the millennium mark. And that’s not going to happen, either.
"I was not on the boat in question." -Darren Sharper
I voted perfect on Pierre, btw. That’s right about where I’d rank him.
"I was not on the boat in question." -Darren Sharper
He hasn’t rushed for over 800 yrds any of his previous 3 season! And yet yall have him getting over 1000 yrds rushing. I guess we all should start a wish list eh? Like with Brees throwing over 35 tds? He hasn’t thrown over 34 in a yr what would suggest he throws over 35? Yet almost 50% of yall say he will throw over 35 tds for the year.
One sleeper that could wind up sneaking into the Top 20 imo: Justin Forsett. He’ll split time with Leon Washington and possibly Julius Jones, but I think he should be pretty productive, especially in the short passing game. No Jerome Harrison mention, either. I’m no fan of Jake Delhomme, but you would have to think he’ll open up that Cleveland offense just a little and I sure as hell don’t see Montario Hardesty posing much of a threat. He’ll be lucky to make it out of training camp in one piece.
"I was not on the boat in question." -Darren Sharper
hey wait a minute
Where’s that San Diego Chargers rookie who is going to take them to the Super Bowl and make everyone forget about LT2 and learn how to catch passes and pass block and …. oh there he is in the honorary mentions.
Not sold on Mendenhall either. All his fans also really liked Willie Parker.
Peace, love and understanding
Tell me, is there no place for them today?
I’d say that’s a little high for Cedric Benson considering his latest assault charges. Given his history and Goodell’s love for laying down the law before the legal system has a chance to, he should be sitting out a few games to start the year.
I’d say its a little high for Ray Rice, but I can understand it. My biggest disagreement is having DeAngelo Williams too low at #10.
"I want to hand this trophy to the MVP of the Super Bowl -- and the MVP of the entire league.''
-- Saints coach Sean Payton, handing the Vince Lombardi Trophy to Drew Brees after Super Bowl 44.
I agree that too high for Rice, if you’re basing it strictly on rushing yards, as is stated the case. It’s about right for yards from scrimmage. DeAngelo Williams seems about right, rushing only. Where’s Stewart, though? They split up the workload pretty evenly last season.
"I was not on the boat in question." -Darren Sharper
I only did technical starters
Since Stewart isn’t the starter I didn’t include him, otherwise he would have been on the list.
I believe Christian Akoya will have a break out season this year.
Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch.
Liberty is a well armed lamb contesting the vote.
Benjamin Franklin
Photo Op
Will have a break out season. He will rush for at least 4 yards per carry.
Underestimate No One, Take Nothing For Granted
How many carries though? 4 yards per carry on 30 carries is definitely not a break out year. 3 yards per carry on 300 carries would be.
"Here's the funny thing. Last night, I couldn't sleep too well. I called my dad (Bill) at 2:15 in the morning, and told him I had a feeling I was going to hit the game-winner from 42 yards on the right hash. I think I was two yards off."- Garrett Hartley
C'mon man
You ruined my shot at the accountability index. *hangs head is disappointment*
This is Photo Op we are talking about, so 4 yards per carry and I say he gets an increased workload as a part of distributing Bell’s workload. I say he doubles his carries from last year, and for him I think that would be a breakout. I also don’t look for him to be in a Saints uniform after this season. That should sweeten the pot enough to get me an honorable mention on the accountability index. :)
Underestimate No One, Take Nothing For Granted
by SaintsFanInIraq on Jul 11, 2010 12:29 AM CDT up reply actions
well now you're just taunting
Lynell had 35 carries for 125 yds last year, 3.6 average. Bell had 172 carries for 654 yds, 3.8 average.
70 carries for Lynell is not a stretch, but I thought they view him as a short yardage back? Hard to get 4 yards a carry in those situations.
The other issue is that if he does meet expectations, they’ll want to keep him as a home grown project success, unlike Mike Bell.
This all annoys me enough, YOU’RE ON THE LIST! GAA!
I was down in Dixie Land, played a silver fiddle
Played it loud and then the man broke it down the middle.
VICTORY IS MINE!!!!!
Underestimate No One, Take Nothing For Granted
by SaintsFanInIraq on Jul 12, 2010 12:08 AM CDT up reply actions
not to bother anyone, but I just want to lighten the mood by posting this movie poster

oh no, I didn’t
"The good news is we're gonna sign you to the roster. The bad news is you're 26 pounds overweight and I gotta fine you, and that's gonna cost you more than you'll make for the playoff game." Sean Payton to Deuce McAllister, January 2010.
am i protected by the "knucklehead laws of the land" here?
"The good news is we're gonna sign you to the roster. The bad news is you're 26 pounds overweight and I gotta fine you, and that's gonna cost you more than you'll make for the playoff game." Sean Payton to Deuce McAllister, January 2010.
by Hans Petersen on Jul 10, 2010 9:10 AM CDT up reply actions
and did oscar-winning Denzel REALLY make his hollywood debut in that film as the long-lost son?
that’s as crazy as someone from He Knows You’re Alone, Bachelor Party, Mazes and Monsters, and Bosom Buddies going on to Oscar status…or is it?
It’s a boring Saturday for me as I seek to entertain myself and the CSC faithful while I wait for my wife to get out of her “fractions class” so we can drive back home…
"The good news is we're gonna sign you to the roster. The bad news is you're 26 pounds overweight and I gotta fine you, and that's gonna cost you more than you'll make for the playoff game." Sean Payton to Deuce McAllister, January 2010.
by Hans Petersen on Jul 10, 2010 9:18 AM CDT up reply actions
maybe I should just finish reading Home Team
"The good news is we're gonna sign you to the roster. The bad news is you're 26 pounds overweight and I gotta fine you, and that's gonna cost you more than you'll make for the playoff game." Sean Payton to Deuce McAllister, January 2010.
by Hans Petersen on Jul 10, 2010 9:19 AM CDT up reply actions
Don’t forget The ’Burbs. Even though everyone else has.
"I was not on the boat in question." -Darren Sharper
yup, and The Money Pit
"The good news is we're gonna sign you to the roster. The bad news is you're 26 pounds overweight and I gotta fine you, and that's gonna cost you more than you'll make for the playoff game." Sean Payton to Deuce McAllister, January 2010.
by Hans Petersen on Jul 10, 2010 9:34 AM CDT up reply actions
it's from the 1981 movie comedy Carbon Copy, starring George Segal and Denzel Washington
"The good news is we're gonna sign you to the roster. The bad news is you're 26 pounds overweight and I gotta fine you, and that's gonna cost you more than you'll make for the playoff game." Sean Payton to Deuce McAllister, January 2010.
by Hans Petersen on Jul 10, 2010 10:50 AM CDT up reply actions
no, the fact that you couldn't get the image up killed the joke, not you
and here’s a link to the image you are missing, so you can get the joke
If we want to do something we've never done before, we've gotta do things we've never done before. -- Drew Brees
by Hans Petersen on Jul 10, 2010 2:14 PM CDT up reply actions
Steven Jackson is a stud RB
I would put him 1st or 2nd Ray Rice maybe 5th Deangelo William ahead of Michael Turner and Ronnie Brown about 6th or 7th
World Champions at last
by mississippisaintsfan on Jul 11, 2010 5:58 PM CDT reply actions
Steven Jackson is good, but is not the best or second best back in the league. As good as he is, he is very injury prone and doesn’t score nearly often enough. Deangelo Williams is not better than Michael Turner, he plays in a run-heavy system with a better run-blocking offensive line. Ronnie Brown is injured way too often to be 6th or 7th best in the league. If he hadn’t been hurt as often as he has been, I would agree with you, but that’s just how it works.
"Here's the funny thing. Last night, I couldn't sleep too well. I called my dad (Bill) at 2:15 in the morning, and told him I had a feeling I was going to hit the game-winner from 42 yards on the right hash. I think I was two yards off."- Garrett Hartley
DeAngelo Williams at #10?
Friend, please. And, where is Jonathan Stewart? That’s just division rivalry hatred, ‘cause there’s no other explanation for it.
stuff 'bout stuff.
I mentioned above I only put technical starters.
Otherwise Jonathan would have been right behind him and 10 is a great spot, hes not the best RB, but hes great which is perfect for 10, and if I had division rivalry hate why did I put Turner at 5 and Thomas at 14?
There's only 32 teams, which means 32 starters.
Number 10 is barely in the top third of the league. That is not where DeAngelo Williams should be. Have you looked up his yards per carry average? Have you seen him play? He’s a top 3 or 4 back. No question. And, that’s with Adrian Peterson ahead of him, which I think is considerate of me considering how often he fumbles.
stuff 'bout stuff.
by silver82blade on Jul 14, 2010 7:01 PM CDT up reply actions
And Steve Breston got the most Yards per carry with 22 yards per carry. And of all RBs on this list, Jamaal Charles had the most YPC with 5.9. YPC is a worthless statistic that I don’t think should be mentioned. Also this list isn’t based on talent, it’s based on yardage, TDs, and fumbles. Which I thought would he would get the 10th most in numbers mentioned.
Please don't compare some WR who only carried it twice to a RB ...
… who carried it over 200 times.
stuff 'bout stuff.
by silver82blade on Jul 14, 2010 7:28 PM CDT up reply actions
I suppose, looking up the rushing totals from last year, you could be right. They give Stewart almost as many carries as Williams, so that eats into his fantasy numbers. So, if you’re looking at it purely from a fantasy football standpoint, it is possible Williams may only rack up 1200-1300, and 9 guys beat him out. I think it’s unlikely 9 guys beat him out if he stays healthy, but it’s possible I guess. But, I’ll reiterate, that’s purely from a fantasy football standpoint, and not a talent one.
stuff 'bout stuff.
by silver82blade on Jul 14, 2010 7:34 PM CDT up reply actions
“YPC is a worthless statistic that I don’t think should be mentioned.”
The importance of EVERY statistic can be downplayed in certain instances. The team with the least TOP occasionally wins the game. Does that make TOP a worthless statistic? The team that gains the most yards doesn’t always come out on top. The highest scoring team in any given season doesn’t always win the Super Bowl. Does this mean that yards gained and points scored are both worthless statistics? The team with BOTH the fewest giveaways and the most takeaways in 2009 (Green Bay) didn’t even make it to the Super Bowl. I guess you can completely write off the importance of turnovers, as well.
"I was not on the boat in question." -Darren Sharper
I’m not talking about team statistics or game statistics but for an individual player, YPC can be a worthless statistic when comparing all RBs unless you have massive sorting based on carrys, games played etc. And in a football game the only stat that matters is the Scoreboard when the clock hits all zeroes.
The score is the statistic that matters MOST. That doesn’t mean it’s the ONLY statistic that matters. Other statistics can be reflective of which team scored more efficiently, for example. Think of a football game as a cross country race. Sure, the team that crosses the finish line first wins. But wouldn’t it behoove that winner to know that he burned twice as much gas as his closest competition? Someone that he edged out by less than an hour? Streamline that problem and the next time he wins, he saves a boatload of money in the process. Or maybe he wins by an even more comfortable margin. That’s the sort of thing that makes most statistics useful.
"I was not on the boat in question." -Darren Sharper

by 


























