Going back to this, I went on NFL.com's "top 100 players" site and came across an application that tally's your votes, from what I'm assuming is the top 100 players on the show, and putting them against each other, essentially making your own top 100 player list (top 10). While having nothing else to do at work I spent about an hour clicking on player after player when I noticed the aforementioned trend going on. They had Brees, Nicks, Vilma, J Evans, Colston, and Bush (giving us 6). In the previous post about this same topic it was given that we had 5 in the top 100 so maybe this isn't the case, or maybe we really do have 6. (although Reggie could be a stretch there)
Also, I do not have NFL Network so I'm not all up to date on the status on the show...so I'm not sure who they have and haven't gone through so far. Any more comments from the peanut gallery?