FanPost

Accountability Index Update

Date Name Assertion Remarks Resolution
Dec 8 2011 Jricky70 Saints @ Titans: This game scares me to be honest. This will be a very tough game. Helplessly handwringing doesn’t make it easier. Peter Finney: “New Orleans Saints show poise in tough road test” Saints 22, Titans 17
Dec 22 2011 MtnExile Saints never win a game after a big Drew BREEESSS!!! game That’s not really what he said but I don’t have room for his excessive verbiage here. @Vikings was a big game? He followed it up with an even bigger game against the Falcons. Maybe M-E was thinking of the Saints losing every final regular season game since the 2005 season.
Dec 7 2011 Dan Kelly PRob WILL NOT CUT IT as our permanent #2 CB. Most think that he’s cutting it adequately when Porter’s covering the slot receiver.
Dec 7 2011 Dan Kelly .If we let Porter go and PRob is our #2 CB next season, we will not win 10 games. We shall see, my pretty.
Sep 19 2011 Frenchie Malcolm Jenkins. 2011 Pro-Bowler. Well… Maybe in our heads.
Nov 9 2011 BlackandGold4ever Packers lose at least 2 games this year. Not in the regular season. Are they vulnerable? I think so. See 2007 Patriots. Except make it the 2011 NFC title game.
Dec 24 2011 tommy Packers lose their first playoff game this year. tommy can’t wait.
Nov 3 2011 stujo4 Peyton Manning will not play another down in the NFL. Yeah, that’s right.
Nov 3 2011 Satch Peyton will play again. Not in the NFL.
Nov 10 2011 TAYDIGGA Manning will be on a new team next year and will pull a Joe Montana (take his new squad to the playoffs). He’ll need a neck transplant first. I hear they’re doing that in Sweden. Early stages, developing the techniques.
Dec 10 2011 Jimbo3 Just 'Nother Day The Colts will keep Peyton Manning in 2012. As a tutor for Luck? Ask the pupils of Ted Williams how that worked out for them.
Oct 4 2011 GSO Saints Fan He will then go the way of JaMarcus Russell…sCam (Cam Newton) is a flash in the pan. A lock for 2011 NFL Rookie of the Year. The kid is good. Admit it and move on. I’m putting this one out of its misery.
Nov 9 2011 Satch The Bucs won’t make the playoffs this year and may even finish behind the Panthers in the division. This, after they picked up Albert Haynesworth. Good call, Satch.
Aug 3 2011 Northfan Saints go 5-1 in division, lose @Tampa 15-1 blah blah Yep yep nope Still an impressive compound prediction, though. Good job.
May 1 2011 GSO Saints Fan The Falcons will begin a steep decline based on this draft. Can it be steep if they make the playoffs? But the fans aren’t happy, here and here.
Aug 3 2011 hansdat Atlanta will hit 9-7 (Julio will fail miserably, and Ryan will do worse than 2010 in passer rating) 10-6, Julio Jones is pretty good (Rotoworld: He's quickly eclipsing Roddy White as the Falcons' best receiver.) And no, Matty’s rating improved to 92.2.
Sep 4 2011 FriarBob I don’t think the Foulclowns will even make the playoffs this year. Well, they’re in, clown face paint and all. Not as good as they thought, but at the dance.
Aug 19 2011 Dan Kelly Matt Ryan will NOT lead the league in TD passes, not even top 3, but maybe top 5 This is true, he came in 6th. But is that bad? I mean, really?
Aug 4 2011 coldpizza Tarvaris Jackson goes .500 in 2011 if he starts an even number of games greater than zero He started 14 and won 7. Some kind of sleight of hand going on here but I’m not smart enough to figure it out.
Aug 4 2011 Breesus Christ Superstar Seahawks go under .500 in 2011 7-9 Revenge is sweet, suckers. Marshawn Lynch is still a beast, though.
Jul 13 2011 Preston J. Gary, Jr. Jimmy Graham: 10 TD’s in 2011 11 Good call.
Apr 29 2011 Jun 8 2011 xen-cuts were gonna need a bigger boat Andrew Juge Ingram pick cost too much with too much risk. Overrated, potential bust. I don’t know how you objectively measure the cost and risk. We can’t call him a bust at this point, can we?
May 1 2011 Hi_Fidelity Ingram has injury concerns, may not have been the best running back prospect in the draft, and doesn’t represent a great upgrade over Thomas/Ivory. and when you consider the price, it was a bad pick unless Ingram puts his butt in the Pro Bowl multiple times or keys another Super Bowl run. It’s turf toe! You’d rather have Demarco Murry? Really? And you’re concerned about injuries? Who knew Payton was going to manage a stable of situational running backs in 2011? Raise your hands… Let’s keep this one open for debate.
Apr 28 2011 HansDat Morstead and 2011 Saints will set NFL record for fewest punts and team record for 6 games without a punt Fewest punts in the leaguefor regular punters, I’ll give you that. There’s always next year!
Apr 24 2011 MtnExile Thinks our run game will be Top 5. 6th in yards, 4th in averageyards per carry. Really pretty good for a Sean “I was a quarterback” Payton.
Aug 15 2011 FuSoYa Saints’ offense will rank in the 12th to 18th range this season 1st in passing, 1st in totaloffense. You one of those decliner fanatics or something? Well, are ya??
Nov 15 2011 tommy Detroit wins at least one game with Green Bay No, not this year. Are you willing to go double or nothing on this in the playoffs?
Oct 4 2011 BlackandGold4ever Eagles won’t make the playoffs. Boom. Notice the date. You’re the only one I know who said it, especially this early. Talk about overrated. Sheesh.
Aug 21 2011 stujo4 Lance and Meachem each have better seasons than Colston (better in 2 out of 3 categories: Receptions, yards, TD’s) Lance 52-627-8 Meachem 40-620-6 Colston 80-1143-8 The decline theory for Colston did not carry on throughout the season after a promising early start, I was wrong.
Aug 21 2011 EasyBreesy Moore’s season more likely to be better than Colston’s than Meachem’s as compared to Colston’s. The odds were with you. Colston had a nice second half of the season, good call.
Apr 28 2011 stujo4 Whoever drafts Da’Quan Bowers will see him balloon up during the inevitable rehab Is ANYONE seeing Da’Quan Bowers, at all?? Ok, he’s not hurt and he’s not a big hog. But you have to concede he was probably drafted too high even without the injury.
May 1 2011 were gonna need a bigger boat Martez Wilson, not Mark Ingram, makes the biggest impact of all rookies this season. This season. Not the last game of the season. I say no. What say you?
May 2 2011 Northfan Wilson probably has the best chance of our drafted rookies to win Rookie of the Year Check the date. What did you guys see in him?? No. But best chance of rookie of the day for Jan 1, 2012, edging out Cam Jordan.
May 4 2011 jray2000 Martez Wilson will be the best overall performer of our draft class What? No. Reassess and get back with me about him for 2012. Will he take Shanle’s job?
May 2 2011 tommy Junior Galette will be a starter this year Yay! He started week 16. He’ll have to find a spot due to injury in 2012 though, right?
Nov 2 2010 Stujo4 The over thrown would be TD pass to Strief in week 8 of 2010 indicates Brees’ QB career peaked in 2009 ahem I heard something about some career highlights this year for Brees, so the peak will have to be marked beyond 2009.
Aug 28 2011 Mr. Dave Drew Brees’ best years are behind him hmm When using the internet, perhaps we should all think about what we are posting, due to the potential perceptions of others.
Jul 14 2011 Satch Drew Brees will prove he is not in decline by throwing less than 10 interceptions and winning the league MVP award 14 picks. Waiting for MVP announcement. Not in decline.
Oct 15 2011 were gonna need a bigger boat Drew Brees wins the MVP award. If he has to share it, does it count?
Aug 15 2011 SaintsFanInIraq Drew Brees will throw 38 TD’s and no more than 14 INT’s this year Wow, 46 and 14. Good call. Did you pray about this? Just a rhetorical question, no answer needed.
Nov 27 2011 cajuncommando58 Drew will throw no more than 2 more INTs for the rest of the regular season. Well, he threw 3 in the last 2 weeks. That was very close, I’ll have to give it to you. I would not have predicted he could turn it around like he did.
Oct 1 2011 were gonna need a bigger boat Drew Brees: 4500+ yds. and 30+ TD’s this season, and that the Saints win at least 12 games 5,476-46-13 Whatsamatta witchoo? You got no faith? A better season than anyone expected.
Dec 16 2011 tommy If Brees goes the rest of the year with no injury, he will become the highest paid QB in the NFL this off season. Tom Condon’s salary demands will provoke the Franchise tag.
Dec 16 2011 BRSaintsFan Dree Brees will NOT become the highest paid QB in the NFL Franchise tag or not, this is probably going to happen.
Jul 14 2011 Satch Pierre Thomas will lead the team for the season in rushing yards and rushing TDs Sproles with 603 yards, PT tied with Ingram with 5 TD’s. Still a nice year, an important member of the committee. Or stable, if you prefer.
May 14 2010 VAsaintsfan Condemned Ricky Williams draft day trade, applauded Tebow draft day trade Tebow does win some games. Is that enough in the NFL? Is that enough to exceed the value of Ricky? Stay tuned for the playoffs.
Jul 2 2011 Preston J. Gary, Jr. Shaun Rogers will make a big impact on defense for the Saints in 2011. He’s old and fat and can you really say he’s fit? I’d say “minimal” rather than “big”. Unless we’re talking about his ass.
Jul 11 2011 coldpizza Shaun Rogers in 2011: 2-3 sacks tops Yeah, how about -0-? “That’s not his specialty, he’s a run stuffer.” Don’t get me started on the Saints’ Roto-Rooter bills again.
Jul 12 2011 coldpizza At least two teams with a new starting QB will make the playoffs this year. At least one of those new QBs will be a rookie Houston and Delhomme? Denver and Tebow. You were probably counting on Gingey Andy and the Bengals, but they let you down. It’s a recurring theme. Beware.

This FanPost was written by a reader and member of Canal Street Chronicles. It does not necessarily reflect the views of CSC and its staff or editors.

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Canal Street Chronicles

You must be a member of Canal Street Chronicles to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Canal Street Chronicles. You should read them.

Join Canal Street Chronicles

You must be a member of Canal Street Chronicles to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Canal Street Chronicles. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9341_tracker