Mark Ingram had nine carries for just 11 yards in the Saints' 23-17 win over the Atlanta Falcons on Sunday. Not the showing anyone hoped to see from the running back. Naturally his performance has sparked a fierce debate among Saints fans trying to determine who or what is more to blame for Ingram's woes: the running back himself or the offensive line?
I figured what better way to get to the bottom of this great argument than to look closer at all nine of Ingram's runs Sunday. So I did just that, and the results are below. Larry Holder did his own film study, and he seems to insinuate that the offensive line was, in fact, more to blame for Ingram's rushing woes.
The answer, honestly, is a little bit of both I think. For the most part, I agree with Larry, the offensive line wasn't giving Ingram any help Sunday. But Ingram failed to capitalize on the few opportunities he did get. So it's difficult to place the blame squarely on one side or the other.
Of Ingram's nine carries, there were five which I thought were unsuccessful because of poor blocking. Let's take a look at them.
2-10-NO 33 (12:39) M.Ingram right end to NO 36 for 3 yards (T.DeCoud)
When Ingram takes the handoff, he sees a potential running lane on the right side (yellow arrow, first frame). But a stunt by Falcons DT Corey Peters mixes up Jahri Evans and allows Peters to fill the intended running lane (yellow arrow, second frame), forcing Ingram to bounce outside. Meanwhile, Ingram's lead blocker, Jed Collins, never picks up safety Thomas DeCoud in time (yellow circle, third frame).
4-1-NO 47 (5:33) M.Ingram right tackle to NO 46 for -1 yards (A.Dent)
Here is the 4th down play. You can see the entire Falcons defensive line is two yards into the backfield by the time Ingram even touches the ball. He's got no chance.
1-10-NO 44 (8:43) M.Ingram right tackle to NO 41 for -3 yards (A.Dent)
On this play, Ben Grubbs gets destroyed, allowing the Falcons defender quickly past him. The play is an immediate bust; Ingram has nowhere to go but tries to make the best of a bad situation. Ingram actually breaks two tackles before the play ends in a loss of 3 yards.
1-10-ATL 45 (13:41) M.Ingram left end ran ob at ATL 42 for 3 yards (D.Trufant)
The entire middle of the field is a traffic jam as Ingram takes it to the outside. Jimmy Graham gets forced into the backfield and Ben Watson can't contain his man and seal the edge, forcing Ingram out of bounds for a short gain.
2-3-ATL 26 (11:35) M.Ingram left end pushed ob at ATL 30 for -4 yards (T.DeCoud)
Ingram takes the handoff and immediately must bounce to the outside because Grubbs is pushed info the backfield (yellow circle, first frame). Meanwhile, Charles Brown gets beat on the left side (yellow circle, second frame), forcing Ingram even further to the outside, where more Falcons are waiting to make the tackle.
1-9-ATL 9 (4:19) M.Ingram right guard to ATL 7 for 2 yards (C.Peters; A.Dent)
Ingram's got a gap between Jahri Evans and Zach Strief and hits it. But DT Corey Peters sheds his block and grabs Ingram by the legs and takes him down as he passes through the hole.
1-10-ATL 12 (5:23) M.Ingram left tackle to ATL 10 for 2 yards (W.Moore)
The blocking is perfect on this run to the left side, and Ingram hits the hole. But William Moore comes flying in untouched from deep safety and nails Ingram (yellow circle, third frame).
2-10-NO 20 (14:56) M.Ingram left tackle to NO 22 for 2 yards (R.McClain)
Ingram takes the handoff, every blocker is paired up, and there's room to run. Things look good on this play. Then Ingram trips over his own two feet.
So there you go, plenty of blame to go around. Ingram's day was certainly made more difficult by a few breakdowns in the run blocking department. But when he had his chances, he wasn't able to exploit them. I'm going to wait a little longer before giving up on Mark Ingram.